Defender Sent-Off in Celtic's Defeat to Hibernian
It was a moment that shifted the entire course of the Scottish Premiership title race. Auston Trusty's straight red card for violent conduct in the 73rd minute proved the decisive turning point as Celtic fell 2-1 to Hibernian at Celtic Park on Sunday. It was manager Martin O'Neill's first domestic defeat of the season and a result that leaves the champions six points behind league leaders Hearts.
The incident itself was contested in its severity. With the scores level at 1-1, Trusty and Hibernian midfielder Jamie McGrath became entangled at a corner, and the American defender forcefully batted away McGrath's arm. Referee Matthew MacDermid initially intended only to speak to both players, but a VAR review changed everything. After being called to the pitchside monitor, MacDermid upgraded his assessment to violent conduct and issued the red card—ending Trusty's afternoon after 74 minutes of otherwise solid defensive work that had included five headed clearances, two interceptions and a perfect aerial duel record.
O'Neill was candid about the impact, acknowledging that Celtic had the momentum at the time of the dismissal and had created chances they simply didn't convert. He stopped short of condemning the decision outright, conceding that thrusting down in the manner Trusty did constitutes violent conduct under current rules, while also noting the original plan had been a simple warning.
The consequences extend beyond Sunday. Trusty now faces missing the Old Firm clash at Ibrox against Rangers next weekend, which is a match Celtic can ill afford to lose, given the gap at the top. An appeal appears unlikely based on O'Neill's comments, meaning the 27-year-old will watch from the stands as his teammates face arguably their biggest test of the season.