Tuesday, November 18, 2025

Best Match Under the New Manager

On This Day in 2024, Pochettino's Revolution Takes Shape as the U.S. Dismantles Jamaica

When Mauricio Pochettino accepted the United States coaching position on September 10, he inherited a program in crisis—not of talent, but of belief. The Copa América elimination had exposed a team that wilted under pressure, that defaulted to conservatism in crucial moments, and that seemed incapable of matching its considerable individual quality with collective performance when the stakes were highest. With less than two years until the 2026 World Cup kicked off on American soil, U.S. Soccer had bet its future on a coach whose résumé suggested he might finally extract maximum value from the most talented generation in program history.

The early evidence had been decidedly mixed. Against Panama in Austin on October 12, the Americans secured a 2-0 victory that provided psychological closure but revealed little about tactical evolution. Three days later, in Guadalajara, Mexico administered a harsh reality check in a 2-0 victory that exposed how much work remained. The performances offered more questions than answers about whether Pochettino's appointment represented a genuine transformation or merely a cosmetic change.

The CONCACAF Nations League quarterfinal against Jamaica represented his first competitive examination. The first leg in Kingston on November 14 produced a 1-0 victory built on Ricardo Pepi's early goal, Matt Turner's penalty save, and Jamaica's late red card. It was professional and necessary, but hardly the kind of dominant display that would ease concerns about the team's ceiling. Four days later, on November 18, the Americans delivered something altogether different.

With 21,080 fans packing CityPark in St. Louis and light rain beginning to fall, the United States dismantled Jamaica in a performance that offered the first genuine evidence that Pochettino's revolution might be taking hold. For 45 minutes, the Americans played the kind of football he had promised when he accepted the job—high-tempo, technically sophisticated, and utterly dominant. Three goals in a 28-minute stretch transformed what had been a nervous 1-0 aggregate advantage into a procession, with Christian Pulisic orchestrating the attack alongside Tim Weah and Weston McKennie. "We came out really hot," Pulisic said afterward. "We should definitely feel good after these results. We're obviously learning a lot of new things with the new coach."

Pochettino made just one change to his starting lineup, inserting Weah for the injured Johnny Cardoso. The decision carried profound symbolic weight—Weah's last appearance in a U.S. jersey had been the red card against Panama that catalyzed the Copa América disaster. His return represented not just roster management but an act of faith in redemption. The tactical setup revealed Pochettino's sophistication. Left back Antonee Robinson inverted into central areas alongside Tanner Tessmann, creating numerical superiority in buildup while Yunus Musah dropped from his right midfield position. Joe Scally pushed higher on the right, and Pulisic drifted wide into the space Robinson had vacated, with Weah maintaining his position on the left wing. The rotations confused Jamaica's defensive structure and created the kind of positional fluidity that had been absent under Gregg Berhalter's more rigid system.

In the 13th minute, the breakthrough arrived. Weston McKennie, operating in a more advanced central role, launched a perfectly weighted long ball over Jamaica's backline. Pulisic timed his run to perfection, meeting the ball on the short hop just inside the penalty area and driving it past the onrushing Andre Blake. The goal was Pulisic's 32nd for the national team, moving him within two of Eric Wynalda for fourth place on the all-time scoring list. The second goal arrived in the 33rd minute through another sequence that began deep in the American half. McKennie sent a diagonal pass toward the top of the box. Tessmann, demonstrating situational awareness that comes from clear tactical instruction, let the ball run through his legs. The dummy froze Jamaica's defenders, and Pulisic's low shot deflected off Di'Shon Bernard's left leg and zipped into the opposite corner. CONCACAF would later rule it an own goal, but the creation belonged entirely to American ingenuity.

By halftime, the match had been effectively decided. Pepi added a third goal in the 42nd minute, collecting a loose clearance from Robinson at the top of the box and unleashing a ferocious right-footed drive into the lower right corner—his first international goal from outside the penalty area and his second in as many matches. "Just about perfect," captain Tim Ream said of the first-half performance. "The movements and the dynamic and getting everybody involved from the get-go, exactly the way we talked about it in the last couple days."

The second half, played in increasingly heavy rain and wind, offered a different kind of test. Jamaica responded through Demarai Gray's side-volley in the 53rd minute, briefly threatening to make the Americans uncomfortable. But Weah answered three minutes later with a moment of individual brilliance that felt like personal catharsis. Musah's cross found him with time and space on the left side of the penalty area. Weah settled the ball calmly before smashing a right-footed half-volley over Blake and just under the crossbar for his seventh international goal. "It's beautiful to see it come together," Weah said afterward, the relief evident in his voice. "That first half was really good and I am excited to see where we can take it."

Gray would add a second goal for Jamaica in the 68th minute, converting a rebound after Turner made a diving save, but the outcome had long since been determined. When the final whistle confirmed the 4-2 victory and 5-2 aggregate triumph, the Americans had secured not just progression to the semifinals but something more valuable—tangible evidence that Pochettino's vision could translate to results. The performance carried particular resonance given the venue and circumstances. Ream, at 37 the oldest player on the roster, captained the team in his hometown. Pulisic, substituted in the 69th minute to a standing ovation, became the fastest player in U.S. history to reach 50 goal contributions, achieving the milestone in just 76 appearances.

The match provided the clearest indication yet that the Americans were beginning to internalize Pochettino's core principles. The positional rotations, the aggressive pressing, the willingness to take risks in possession—these were not merely tactical adjustments but evidence of a mentality shift that had seemed impossible during Copa América's dark summer. The victory secured the United States' place in the semifinals, scheduled for March 20 at SoFi Stadium in Inglewood, California, where they would defend their title as three-time defending Nations League champions. More importantly, it provided a foundation of belief heading into what would be a long winter without the full player pool—Pochettino's next camp would feature primarily MLS-based players for a January 18 friendly against Venezuela, with most European-based regulars unavailable outside the FIFA international window.

The dismissal of Berhalter after Copa América had represented an acknowledgment that potential without results was insufficient. Four matches into Pochettino's tenure, the evidence remained incomplete—friendlies against Panama and Mexico, followed by two matches against a Jamaica side that would finish outside the top 50 in FIFA rankings. But the first-half performance against Jamaica offered something that had been notably absent during Copa América: proof that this generation of American players, when properly organized and confidently directed, could produce the kind of football that justified the program's lofty ambitions.

As Pochettino addressed his players after the match, he emphasized not the victory itself but the journey ahead. "My advice is look after yourself," he told them, knowing the team would not reconvene at full strength until March. "We need to be stronger in March. We need to be desperate to arrive by March and to be all together. That is a sign that we improve a lot and then we start to feel that we are a real group of people, that we are going to fight for something special."

Just six camps with the top player pool remained before Pochettino would select his 2026 World Cup roster. The performance against Jamaica suggested the revolution had begun, but revolutions are measured not in single matches but in sustained excellence against elite opposition. For a program that had spent the summer confronting its limitations, the dominant victory represented progress—meaningful, measurable, and desperately needed. Whether it would prove sufficient when the stakes reached their peak in 2026 remained the question that would define not just Pochettino's tenure but the legacy of an entire generation.

The dream of proving themselves among soccer's elite, deferred so painfully in Kansas City four months earlier, was being rebuilt one performance at a time. On a rainy November night in St. Louis, with Weah's redemptive goal still echoing and Pulisic's celebration still fresh, it felt possible again.

No comments:

Post a Comment