On This Day in 2009, After Confederations Cup Success, the US B-Squad Went Unbeaten in Group Play at the Gold Cup
The success in South Africa still lingered in the summer air, but the faces were different now. Two weeks after stunning the soccer world by reaching the Confederations Cup final—after leading Brazil 2-0 at halftime before heartbreak struck in a 3-2 defeat—the United States Men's National Team had transformed once again. Gone were most of the heroes who had shocked Spain and nearly toppled the five-time World Cup champions. In their place stood a collection of Major League Soccer regulars, promising youngsters and veterans fighting their way back from injury, all carrying the weight of maintaining momentum that had suddenly made American soccer relevant on the global stage.
Coach Bob Bradley faced a peculiar challenge as the 2009 CONCACAF Gold Cup approached. His team had just achieved something unprecedented in American soccer history, yet he couldn't field the same squad that had created those magical moments in South Africa. The realities of club commitments, European pre-seasons, and simple human exhaustion meant that only four players from the Confederations Cup roster would begin the Gold Cup campaign. Charlie Davies was the sole player who had actually featured in games against Italy, Brazil, and Spain just weeks earlier.
"Our goal is obviously to win the tournament," declared Steve Cherundolo, the 30-year-old right back who had watched the Confederations Cup from home while recovering from hip surgery. "Anyone who doesn't have that goal shouldn't be here." Cherundolo understood the burden better than most—he had been sidelined since November, undergoing surgery in April while his teammates were making history without him. Now, returning to action in the Gold Cup carried the same weight as facing Spain or Brazil. The tournament represented redemption, opportunity, and the chance to prove that American soccer's depth matched its newfound ambition.
The opening match against Grenada in Seattle provided the perfect stage for this experiment in continuity. The Americans, ranked 12th in the world, faced the 88th-ranked island nation in front of 15,387 fans at Qwest Field in Seattle. Seven of the starting eleven entered the match with a combined total of just eleven international appearances, with 23-year-old Stuart Holden making his international debut. The result was emphatic: a 4-0 victory that showcased the program's evolving depth. Freddy Adu opened the scoring in the seventh minute, capitalizing on a cross from Robbie Rogers. Holden announced his arrival on the international stage with a leaping header in the 31st minute, becoming the first American to score in his debut since Eddie Robinson had done so against Sweden in January 2008. Rogers added a goal of his own in the 60th minute, and Davies—the veteran of the group despite his youth—finished the scoring eight minutes later.
Three days later, in Washington, D.C., the Americans faced a sterner test against Honduras at RFK Stadium. The match provided a stage for one of the tournament's most compelling personal stories. Santino Quaranta, making his first appearance for the United States in more than three years, had publicly acknowledged his battles with drug and alcohol addiction. His journey back to the national team through D.C. United represented more than athletic redemption—it was a testament to the power of second chances.
"To listen to the anthem was very emotional for me," Quaranta reflected. "It's been a fun, long road back." The crowd of 26,079 had a pro-Honduras bent, but there were enough American supporters to create an atmosphere charged with possibility. Quaranta rewarded their faith in the 75th minute, taking a short pass from Davies at the top of the penalty box and firing home his first international goal. Brian Ching added a header four minutes later to secure a 2-0 victory that maintained the Americans' perfect record in Gold Cup group play.
However, it was the final group match against Haiti at Gillette Stadium on July 11 that provided the most vivid reminder of how quickly momentum can shift in international soccer. The Americans arrived in Foxborough knowing that a draw would secure first place in Group B. Haiti, meanwhile, had their own dreams of advancing to the knockout rounds for the first time in their Gold Cup history. The match began perfectly for the United States. In the sixth minute, Stuart Holden—who had already established himself as one of the tournament's breakout stars—set up the opening goal with a simple but effective pass to Davy Arnaud. The Kansas City Wizards forward managed to control the ball long enough to chip a delicate left-footed shot past the tumbling Jean Dominique Zephirin. The early goal should have settled American nerves, but instead it seemed to create a false sense of security.
"We scored an early goal and that was a good thing, but I think it came so early that we hadn't really found a rhythm in the game yet," Bradley would later observe. "As a result, after that, we were still trying to find our rhythm. They were able to make some plays and cause some trouble."
The second half began with a reminder of how quickly soccer can humble even the most prepared teams. Just 46 seconds after the restart, Leonel Saint Preux delivered a cross from the right side that found Sirin Vaniel at the far post. The Haitian forward lunged with a perfectly timed header that beat Luis Robles despite the goalkeeper's five saves on the night. Three minutes later, Haiti struck again in devastating fashion. Jay Heaps, the New England Revolution defender making his international debut, attempted to clear a dangerous ball toward the center of the field. The clearance was rushed, imperfect, and landed directly at the feet of Mones Chery, who was positioned about 35 yards from goal. What followed was a moment of pure inspiration—Chery unleashed a thunderous shot that rocketed past Robles into the upper corner of the net.
The psychological impact was immediate and profound. For Bradley, watching from the sideline, the moment carried additional weight. "Certainly any of us who were in South Africa don't need a second reminder about what it's like to give up a goal 45 seconds into the second half," he would say. "That is one that is stuck with us forever." Haiti's coach Jairo Rios watched his team's transformation with evident pride. "What an irony," he mused. "The poorest country in the world against what could be considered the superpower of the world and they could be able to hold themselves on the field, demonstrating the real passion for the game from the players." His team was not just competing—they were leading, and threatening to secure their first victory over the United States since a 1-0 win in San Diego in May 1969.
The Americans pressed forward with increasing desperation as the minutes ticked away. Bradley made tactical adjustments, introducing Davies and Kyle Beckerman in the 63rd minute, followed by Ching in the 76th. The fresh legs brought renewed energy, but Haiti's defense held firm through wave after wave of American attacks. In the 85th minute, Davies created what seemed like the equalizer when Arnaud lobbed a pass that caught the New Hampshire native in the chest. Davies managed to control the ball and unleash a right-footed shot, but it was blocked in front of the goal. The crowd of 24,137 at Gillette Stadium—many of whom had come to watch the Revolution play Kansas City in the evening's opening match—sensed that time was running out for the Americans. In the first minute of second-half stoppage time, with Haiti defending desperately and the Americans throwing everything forward, Holden found himself with space 25 yards from goal. The Houston Dynamo midfielder, who had already established himself as the tournament's most consistent performer, unleashed a shot that sailed past Zephirin into the upper right corner of the net.
"We were pushing the whole second half," Holden said afterward. "We kept knocking on the door, and the chance fell to me." The goal was his second of the tournament and his third contribution to American scoring, having also assisted on Arnaud's opener. More importantly, it preserved the United States' unblemished record in Gold Cup group play and secured first place in Group B. The 2-2 draw was a lesson in resilience for a team still learning to carry the expectations that came with their newfound prominence. As the group stage concluded, the United States had achieved its primary objective while gaining valuable experience in high-pressure situations. The team that had surprised the world in South Africa was gone, replaced by a collection of players still learning to play together, still building the chemistry that would be essential in the knockout rounds ahead. Their next match would come in Philadelphia, where they would face either Jamaica or the third-place finisher from Group C.
"When you begin the tournament, the goal is to win your group and advance," Bradley said after the match. "So the first thing that we said after the game is, 'We've accomplished that goal.'" The path forward remained uncertain, but the Americans had demonstrated character in their dramatic escape against Haiti. The road to a third consecutive Gold Cup title stretched ahead, and the lessons learned in that frantic final minute against Haiti would prove invaluable in the challenges to come. Sometimes, in soccer as in life, the most important victories are the ones that feel like defeats until the very last moment.